Because I look at a lot of studies when I saw the headline Most Complementary Medicines Have No Effect For People With Rheumatoid Arthritis; Picture More Hopeful For Osteoarthritis Patients I thought what research is this? What complementary medicines were they talking about? The report was published by Arthritis Research Campaign and the article in its entirety can be found here.
The report gave full marks for the effectiveness of fish oil in rheumatoid arthritis and full marks for capsaicin gel for osteoarthritis. In all 40 complementary medicine products were looked at. The review included singular botanicals, single nutrients, and combination/polyherbal products such as Eazmov, Gytadyl and Rheumalex. Homeopathy was briefly covered. The report only looked at products that were taken orally or applied topically. Other products that were covered were antler velvet and green lipped mussels. They do not include acupuncture or chiropractic care in their review. The report looked at only randomized controlled trials (RCT) and is very well laid out and easy to read. They use a very succinct grading system for all products they looked at.
The title would have you conclude that complementary medicine is not useful in the treatment of rheumatoid or osteoarthritis ( they also looked at 4 products and fibromyalgia). However, by only looking at RCT's that addressed individual products they have not considered the complete treatment offered by a CAM professional. Also some of these products are mainly from the health food store market place and not likely to be used by a professional that would customize their herbal blend using herbals not even addressed here. There is also no mention of traditional use herbals or using that knowledge in the treatment of arthritis. Food sensitivity and diet is not addressed either. This report offers a quick reference guide for the 40 products covered that have RCT data.
Sabra Way MNIMH
Editor in Chief and Founder, Galen's Watch
Galen's Watch reports on complementary and alternative medical literature that is relevant to CAM practitioners. Visit our journal watch service and see the medical journals we scan regularly.